050308 :Lab test ‘revolution’ predicted for anti-ageing skin creams

By Jeremy Laurance, Health Editor
Wednesday, 23 April 2008

A revolution in the marketing of anti-ageing skin creams based on scientific evaluation of their effects was predicted yesterday by leading dermatologists.

Results of the first double blind randomised controlled trial of a skin-care product are awaited and could trigger a flood of similar trials as companies compete for domination of the multimillion-pound market, the experts said.

The race to develop a scientifically proven over-the-counter product with comparable anti-ageing effects to retinoic acid, the remedy for sun-damaged skin developed as a treatment for acne more than 30 years ago, heralded a new era in the approach to skin-care products, they said.

Retinoic acid causes side effects of redness, dryness and irritation in about 1 per cent of users and is only available on prescription. Over-the-counter versions contain very small amounts of the agent and are of limited effectiveness.

The clinical trial of the Boots No 7 Protect and Perfect beauty serum, which is claimed to have significant anti-ageing properties, was launched after initial laboratory tests showed it worked better than more expensive creams in repairing skin damaged by the effects of the sun and ageing.

After the laboratory tests were shown last year on the BBC TV Horizon programme, they triggered a run on the Boots cream and near-riots when stocks ran out, proving the marketing power of hard science. Boots sold almost six million 30ml tubes of the beauty serum at £16.75 each in the nine months after the programme. Yesterday, Chris Griffiths, professor of dermatology at the University of Manchester, who tested the cream for Horizon and is leading the clinical trial, was astonished by the response. “It showed how science is something the public latch on to,” he said, at a briefing organised by the Science Media Centre.

The cream contains white lupin and retinyl parmitate, a derivative of retinol (Vitamin A) which was shown 30 years ago to reduce brown spots and wrinkling associated with ageing. Professor Griffiths said there had been a “lot of conjecture” about which of the two ingredients accounted for the effects in the laboratory tests, which showed the cream stimulated production of fibrillin.

Fibrillin is essential to the structure of the skin, in the same way tent-pegs hold a groundsheet smooth, but it is destroyed by the effects of the sun and ageing, he said. Although the laboratory tests suggested the Boots cream had a positive effect on fibrillin, there was no way of knowing if it improved appearance until the results of the clinical trial were revealed. “It may do absolutely nothing,” he said.

Whatever the outcome, the pressure for more scientific evaluation of skin cream manufacturer’s claims was irresistible, said Richard Weller, consultant dermatologist at the University of Edinburgh.

The market for “cosmaceuticals” – cosmetics sold on the basis of their supposed scientific effects – has doubled in the past five years to £100m. But there was little trial evidence to prove their effects, Dr Weller said.

“There are half a dozen major companies operating in the same market with essentially similar products. If one took the risk [of running trials] and it paid off, you would have the killer company. It would dominate the market. It’s a high-risk strategy but I think one of them will do it.”

What restrained the companies was the fear that, if their products proved too effective in scientific trials they could be classed as medicines, restricting their sale over the counter and making them available only on prescription, like retinoic acid. The battle then would be with the regulators over the definition of the product. Dr Weller said: “If I ran a cosmetics company I would say, let’s do it.”

Best seller

6,000,000: Number of 30ml tubes of Boots No 7 Protect and Perfect sold in nine months after favourable lab test

• Singaporeborn Teen Discovers Tree Pulps Antiageing Benefits

  Her super antioxidant compound could one day help improve health and antiageing products. AFP

• Avocado Oil Linked To Antiageing

  Avocado oil may have antiageing properties like those attributed to olive oil, say researchers.

• The Beauty Of Antiageing Avocados

  Avocado oil may have antiageing properties like those attributed to olive oil, researchers say.

• Plant Compound Boosts Cell Energy

  Hopes of developing antiageing drugs have been given a boost by new research involving an ingredient in red wine.

• Antiageing Salads

  One look at her celeb and non clients and Dr Chiranjiv Chhabra, dermatologist and cosmetic surgeon to Bollywood stars, socialites and politicoswithsocietyaspirations, is able to pinpoint exactly what is wrong with their skins.

• Colladeen Visage: Antiageing And SPF You Canswallow?

  I have come across a new pill with big promises, ladies and gentleladies. Meet Colladeen Visage a supplement that promises to reduce wrinkles, improve elasticity and even provide an internal SPF of 10 yes, by swallowing a pill. Now, I am pretty strict with my skincare regime, so Im not going to claim this is a miracle after photo youre seeing. The photo above is a hires snap of my face …

• Reader Road Test: Antiageing Serum

  Do costly serums really make a difference to your skin? Five brave Life Style readers put Estee Lauders Advanced Night Repair serum to the test, with surprising results.

• Simon Cowells Youthful Secret

  TVs Mr Nasty appears to have swapped botox for botanics.

• Avocado Joins The Superfood Club

  Avocado oil may have antiageing properties similar to those attributed to olive oil, researchers have claimed.

• Look Brighter

  WELLknown for its antiageing products, StriVectin now offers a brighter future with its new StriVectinWH PhotoWhite range.